Ad Free 2-day Shipping On Millions of Items. Read customer reviews find best sellers. 5 Tips To Applying And Wearing Bottom Eyeliner Stylecaster Save gels creams and liquid for your eyelid and lightly run a pencil eyeliner along your bottom lashes. . Recently cosmetic eyelid tattooing also known as permanent eye-liner has experienced an upsurge in popularity. The second answer is that yes eyeliner on top does make your eyes look smaller or bigger. The secret to lining the inner rims of the eyes is to layer the color. Liquid eyeliner is meant to be used on your top lid. However if you have big eyes and dark colored ones like blue or black then eyeliner on top will not help you at all. This is because it makes the bottom part of your eyelids appear to be wider than the rest of your eyelids. Using the wrong eyeliner formula. By Natalie Gontcharova Published. If you use it on the bottom of your eye you are alm...